3. Power to apply
to the Court in respect of trusts of a charitable or religious nature .
4. Contents and
verification of petition.
6. Failure of
trustee to comply with order under Section 5.
7. Powers of
trustee to apply for direction.
8. Costs of
petition under this Act.
11. Provisions of
the Code of Civil Procedure to apply.
________________
An Act to provide more effectual control over the administration of
Charitable and Religious Trusts.
Whereas it is expedient to
provide facilities for the obtaining of information regarding trusts created
for public purposes of a charitable or religious nature, and to enable the
trustees of such trusts to obtain the directions of a Court on certain matters,
and to make special provision for the payment of the expenditure incurred in
certain suits against the trustees of such trusts; it is hereby enacted as
follows:
1. Short title and extent. — (1) The Act may be called
the Charitable and Religious Trusts Act, 1920.
(2) It extends to the whole
of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir :
Provided that the Government
of any State may, by notification in the Official Gazette direct that this Act,
or any specified parts thereof, shall not extend to the State or any specified
area therein or to any specified trust or class of trusts.
Comments
Under this Act, District
Judge acts as a Court of Law and not as a persona designate. District Judge's
Court is a court subordinate to the High Court. (AIR 1929 All 581)
3. Power to apply to the Court in respect of trusts of a
charitable or religious nature. — Save as
hereinafter provided in this Act, any person having an interest in any express
or constructive trust created or existing for a public purpose of a charitable
or religious nature may apply by petition to the Court within the local limits
of whose jurisdiction any substantial part of the subject-matter of the trust
is situate to obtain an order embodying allo or any of the following
directions, namely:
(1) directing the trustee
to furnish the petitioner through the Court with particulars as to the nature
and object of the trust, and of the subject-matter of the trust and of the
income belonging thereto or as to any of these matters; and
(2) directing that the
accounts of the trust shall be examined and audited:
Provided that no person shall
apply for any such direction in respect of accounts relating to a period more
than three years prior to the date of the petition.
Comments
The District Judge has
jurisdiction to entertain and decide an application an application under
Section 3 of the Charitable and Religious Trusts Act for an order calling upon
the trustees of a Muslim trust property to furnish accounts. (AIR 1948 Nagpur 183)
The question as to whether
the religious endowment or of a private nature or of a public nature has to be
decided with reference to the facts proved in each case and it is difficult to
lay down any test or tests which may be of universal application (AIR 1981 S.C.
798)
A mosque built with public
subscriptions and used by muhammadan public for offering prayers was held a
“religious trust” within the meaning of Section 3. (AIR 1936 Lahore 695)
4. Contents and verification of petition. — (1) The petition shall show
in what way the petitioner claims to be interested in the trust, and shall
specify as far as may be, the particulars and the audit which he seeks to
obtain.
(2) The petition shall be in
wirting and shall be signed and verified in the manner prescribed by the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908, for signing and verifying plaints.
5. Procedure on petition. — (1) If the Court on receipt
of a petition under Section 3, after taking such evidence and making such
inquiry, if any, as it may consider necessary, is of opinion that the trust to
which the petition relates is a trust to which this Act applies and that the
petitioner has an interest therein, it shall fix a date for the hearing of the
petition, and shall cause a copy thereof, together with notice of the date so
fixed, to be served on the trustee and upon any other person to whom in its
opinion notice of the petition should be given.
(2) On the date fixed for the
hearing of the petition or on any subsequent date to which the hearing may be
adjourned, the Court shall proceed to hear the petitioner and the trustee, if
he appears, and any other person who has appeared in consequence of the notice,
or who it considers ought to be heard, and shall make such further inquiries,
if any, as it thinks fit. The trustee may and, if so required by the Court,
shall at the time of the first hearing or which such time as the Court may
permit, present a written statement of his case. If he does present a written
statement, the statement shall be signed and verified in the manner prescribed
by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, for signing and verifying pleadings.
(3) If any person appears at
the hearing of the petition and either denies the existence of the trust or
denies that it is a trust to which this Act applies, and undertakes to
institute within three months a suit for a declaration to that effect and for
any other appropriate relief, the Court shall order a stay of the proceedings
and, if such suit is so instituted, shall continue the stay until, the suit is
finally decided.
(4) if such undertaking is
given, or if after the expiry of the three months no such suit has been
instituted, the Court shall itself decide the question.
(5) On completion of the
inquiry provided for in sub-section (2), the Court shall either dismiss the
petition or pass thereon such order as it thinks fit:
Provided that, where a suit
has been instituted in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (3), no
order shall be passed by the Court which conflicts with the final decision
therein.
(6) Save as provided in this
section, the Court shall not try or determine any question of title between the
petitioner and any person claiming title adversely to the trust.
6. Failure of trustee to comply with order under Section
5. — If a
trustee without reasonable excuse fails to comply with an order made under
sub-section (5) of Section 5, such trustee shall without prejudice to any other
penalty or liability which he may incur under any law for the time being in
force, be deemed to have committed a breach of trust affording ground for a
suit under the provisions of Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
and any such suit may, so far as it is based on such failure, be instituted
without the previous consent of the Advocate General.
Comments
The terms of Section 6 are
intended to define the consequences of the orders made by the District Judge.
But the words “if a trustee without reasonable cause fails to comply” in the
section cannot be read to exclude a contention in a regular suit that the
plaintiff is not a trustee or to prevent a similar contention being raised by a
defendant to a suit under Section 92 C.P.C. (AIR 1940 P.C. 7)
7. Powers of trustee to apply for direction. — (1) Save as hereinafter
provided in this Act, any trustee of an express or constructive trust created
or existing for public purpose of a charitable or religious nature may apply by
petition to the Court, within the local limits of whose jurisdiction any
substantial part of the subject-matter of trust is situate, for the opinion,
advice or direction of the Court on any question affecting the management or
administration of the trust property, and the court shall give its opinion,
advice or direction, as the case may be thereon.
Provided that the Court shall
not be bound to give such opinion, advice or direction on any question which it
considers to be a question not proper for summary disposal.
(2) The court on a petition
under sub-section (1), may either give its opinion, advice or direction thereon
forthwith, or fix a date, for the hearing of the petition, and may direct a
copy thereof, together with notice of the date so fixed, to be served on such
of the persons interested in the trust, or to be published for information in
such manner, as it thinks fit.
(3) On any date fixed under
sub-section (2) or on any subsequent date, to which the hearing may be
adjourned, the Court, before giving any opinion, advice or direction, shall
afford a reasonable opportunity of being heard to all persons appearing in
connection with the petition.
(4) A trustee stating in good
faith the facts of any matter relating to the trust in a petition under
sub-section (1), and acting upon the opinion, advice or direction of the Court
given thereon, shall be deemed, as far as his own responsibility is concerned,
to have discharged his duty as such trustee in the matter in respect of which
the petition was made.
Comments
Application by trustees for
permission to sell immovable properties and wind up the trust is maintainable
under Section 7. (AIR 1974 Delhi 228).
8. Costs of petition under this Act. — The costs, charges and
expenses of and incidental to any petition, and all proceedings in connection
therewith under the foregoing provisions of this Act, shall be in the
discretion of Court, which may direct the whole or any part of any such costs,
charges and expenses to be met from the property or income of the trust in
respect of which the petition is made or to be borne and paid in such manner
and by such person as it thinks fit:
Provided that no such order
shall be made against any person (other than the practitioner) who has not
received notice of the petition and had a reasonable opportunity of being heard
thereon.
9. Savings. — No petition under the foregoing provisions of this Act
in relation to any trust shall be entertained in any of the following
circumstances, namely:
(a) if a suit instituted
in accordance with the provisions of Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, is pending in respect of the trust in question;
(b) if the trust property
is vested in the Treasurer of Charitable Endownments, the
Administrator-General, the Official Trustee, or any Society registered under
the Societies Registration Act, 1860; or
(c) if a scheme for the
administration of the trust property has been settled or approved by any Court
of competent jurisdiction, or by any other authority acting under the
provisions of any enactment.
10. Power of Courts as to costs in certain suits against
trustees of charitable and religious trusts. — (1) In any suits instituted
under Section 14 of the Religious Endownments Act, 1863, or under Section 92 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 the Court trying such suit may, if on
application of the plaintiff and after hearing the defendant and making such
enquiry as it thinks fit, it is satisfied that such an order is necessary in
the public interest, direct the defendant either to furnish security for any
expenditure incurred or likely to be incurred by the plaintiff in instituting
and maintaining such suit, or to deposit from any money in his hands as
trustees of the trust to which the suit relates such sum as such Court
considers sufficient to meet such expenditure in whole or in part .
(2) When any money has been
deposited in accordance with an order made under sub-section (1), the Court may
make over to the plaintiff the whole or any part of such sum for the conduct of
the suit. Before making over any sum to the plaintiff, the Court shall take
security from the plaintiff, for the refund of the same in the event of such
refund being subsequently ordered by the Court.
11. Provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure to apply.
— (1) The
provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, relating to, —
(a) the proof of facts by
affidavit;
(b) the enforcing of the attendance
of any person and his examination on oath;
(c) the enforcing of the
production of documents; and
(d) the issuing of
commissions;
shall apply to all
proceedings under this Act, and the provisions relating to the service of
summons shall apply to the service of notice thereunder.
(2) The provisions of the
said Code relating to the execution of decrees shall, so far as they are
applicable, apply to the execution of orders under this Act.
12. Barring of appeals. — No appeal shall lie from any
order passed or against any opinion, advice or direction given under this Act.